Tuesday, January 7, 2020

The Best of the 2010s: 20 for 2020



Amid all the list making and best-of roundups, there are films bound to be forgotten. Among these are great films, some heralded in their time and some less so, but all of which deserve to be remembered and shared as the years and decades go on. Last Cinema Standing will, of course, be compiling our Best of the Decade lists and sharing them in this space. We will talk about the best moments in film, the best performances, and the best films, but I wanted to start off this project with the films that might not end up in these other places.

I initially planned to have here a list of movies that should be revisited so as not to be forgotten, but as with so many things, the idea morphed and transformed in the process. What we have instead are the movies that for whatever reason, I could not stop thinking about as the years have passed. Some are big blockbusters while others are little-seen indies, but none has left my mind. So, here are 20 movies – two for each year of the 2010s – that I will be thinking about in 2020 and beyond and that I hope you will give another watch to in the decade to come.

Exit Through the Gift Shop (2010)

Remember when Banksy was nominated for an Oscar? That was no joke, except perhaps on the Academy for buying into the veracity of the notoriously prank-happy street artist’s supposed documentary. But “fact or fiction?” is not really the point in Exit Through the Gift Shop. If you accept it as a documentary, then it is a documentary. If you view it as a satirical jab at the world of high art, then that is what it is.

The characters are verifiably real – or as verifiable as anyone in this world gets – with Mr. Brainwash, Space Invader, Shepard Fairey, and Banksy himself all making appearances. The film captures the guerilla nature of their work but also the craftsmanship inherent in the planning, preparation, and execution of their schemes. It then goes beyond that into the commodification of all that work, questioning the very nature of art as a business.

It is undeniable that Exit Through the Gift Shop is an elaborate practical joke, but on whom will change based on your perspective. Is it on the high-art world, which is shown to be shallow and corruptible? Is it on the street artists, who allow themselves to be taken in by Mr. Brainwash? Is it on us for getting dragged into any of this? Or maybe the joke is ultimately on Banksy, for thinking any of us would get what he was doing in the first place.

See also: 127 Hours, Danny Boyle’s stirring tribute to the human spirit, which gives us James Franco’s finest performance, a wonderful A.R. Rahman score, and one of the most beautiful and uplifting finales of the decade.

Rise of the Planet of the Apes (2011)

The revitalization of the Planet of the Apes series is one of the most pleasantly surprising developments of the past decade. Though many of the films are enjoyable, the original series essentially peaked with the twist at the end of the first film. Charlton Heston damns us all to hell, and it is basically downhill from there, give or take an Escape from the Planet of the Apes. Tim Burton’s widely loathed 2001 Planet of the Apes left neither hope nor much desire for a revival.

So, imagine the delight of sitting down for another reboot in a decade of full of them and instead getting a startlingly original vision that refuses to trade on the nostalgia of its predecessors and forges a new path forward. Director Ruper Wyatt strikes gold with the story of a chimpanzee accidentally granted sentience and a society that has no idea how to handle that development. As ever, though, this tale about the rise of another species is truly about the fatal flaw in humanity that precipitates our own downfall.

Of course, Andy Serkis is great as Caesar, the central chimp, and we will talk more about him in another installment of this series. The visual effects work, to this point, was unmatched. How Joe Letteri and team lost the Oscar will be puzzled over. But Wyatt does not rely solely on performance and effects, and in the end, he stages one of the great battle scenes of the decade on the Golden Gate Bridge. He imbues the sequence with the weight it deserves, portraying humanity’s last stand for the futile gesture it is and, perhaps, always was.

See also: Drive, a tangerine dream of a film that made a lot of people (yours truly included) think they could be cool just by throwing on a scorpion jacket and remaining stoic. Perhaps no one will ever be as cool as director Nicolas Winding Refn makes Ryan Gosling look in this movie.



Prometheus (2012)

In 2012, I called director Ridley Scott’s Alien prequel the best film of the year. It was not a well-liked film, and its esteem has not grown in the intervening years. At the time, I thought it was an estimable science-fiction masterpiece. Masterpiece was probably too strong – the film is silly in places and has surface-level flaws I missed while admiring its depths. I still admire its depths. In the wake of Alien: Covenant, I find still more to like in Prometheus.

It is fascinating the four original Alien films were handled by four distinct directors, each putting his spin on the material. Of them, only Scott returned to the franchise. Perhaps, this is because he was the only one who had something left to say on the matter. Taken together, Prometheus and Alien: Covenant reach for a grand statement on humanity’s origins and our never-ending quest to find meaning beyond ourselves.

The android David (Michael Fassbender) is one of the great characters of the decade. He represents both human ingenuity and human vanity. He is the best of our intentions and the worst of our actions. He is both the pride and the fall. He is the film’s final verdict on what we are. Maybe Prometheus does not achieve all its goals, but for setting its aims so high, it is to be applauded.

See also: Chronicle, which like so much else in recent times has been stained by problematic men behind the scenes but which remains the second-best superhero film of a decade dominated by superheroes. Dane DeHaan is marvelous, and as a latecomer to The Wire who never watched Friday Night Lights, this was my introduction to the one, the only Michael B. Jordan.

Inside Llewyn Davis (2013)

This is an already well-regarded film by two of the preeminent filmmakers of the era, which is to say Joel and Ethan Coen’s Inside Llewyn Davis is not exactly at risk of being forgotten. On the contrary, it will be at or near the top of many best-of-the-decade lists, I suspect. And while it will not be on my list, Inside Llewyn Davis is a film that has not left my mind since I saw it. It sticks with you and demands attention, not unlike the cat Oscar Isaac’s Llewyn picks up as a traveling companion.

Adam Driver gave an interview to the New Yorker a couple months back in which he stated he no longer watches his own performances, citing his performance in this film as a reason why. In particular, he mentioned the famous “Please, Mr. Kennedy” sequence, which is the most out-and-out funny moment in a movie that is otherwise blackly comic at the best of times. I bring this up because at Driver’s mere mention of the scene, my mind spiraled in a dozen different directions, analyzing the film’s structure, its humor, and its performances, all of which remain richly nuanced on every viewing.

The story is not so much a straight line of incidents but a densely interwoven tapestry of accidents and ironies – all meticulously planned by the Coens, of course. Though I do not have this on my list of the best films of the decade, it tops the list of films I have thought about most in the past 10 years. It is impossible not to think of Llewyn and his brushes with greatness, his travels parallel to the road that leads to success and fame, a road he will never walk.

See also: Stories We Tell, Sarah Polley’s poignant and pointed work of autobiography, functioning both as a deeply felt exploration of the relationship between parents and their children and a larger investigation of the nature of truth and truth-telling.

Inherent Vice (2014)

In a decade that saw Paul Thomas Anderson produce two universally acclaimed masterworks (The Master and Phantom Thread), it is the film that came between those two that stands out the most in my mind as a hidden gem. It is truly PTA’s middle child of the decade – forgotten, underappreciated, and a little bitter. Where The Master and Phantom Thread trade on their mannered stateliness, Inherent Vice is an irreverent freakout, content in its strangeness and unbothered by its messiness.

Adapted from a seemingly unfilmable Thomas Pynchon novel, Inherent Vice is less about its twisty, private-eye mystery plot than it is about a mood. With an all-time Joaquin Phoenix performance at its center, the film tangles you up in knots, daring you to pull at any thread and see what happens. Sometimes, it feels as though the film itself is unsure what will happen if you look too closely, though of course, Anderson is always in control, no matter how out of control his creation seems to be.

The hippie dream has never been portrayed as foggier or more distant than here, where characters walk around seemingly aware that any change they longed for has eluded them and any peace they sought has curdled into boredom and discontentment. Anderson knows this, and his film is unafraid to show us how all that bitterness builds up in those who had so much hope dashed so unceremoniously. And, suddenly, all the fun stops, and we are left with only emptiness, and we can hardly picture what once may have filled the void.

See also: Mr. Turner, about what happens when a world we thought we knew passes us by and we are left to reflect on what remains. Mike Leigh delivers a gorgeously shot tribute to the life and work of a singular artist that serves as a reminder of what makes all artists special and just a little crazy.


The Kindergarten Teacher (2015)

I have not seen Sara Colangelo’s 2018 remake of this film. I hear Maggie Gyllenhaal is exceptional in the title role. Considering I can think of no bad Gyllenhaal performances, I am sure that she is. But we already have Sarit Larry’s sublime performance in Nadav Lapid’s original, and to ask for more would seemingly be greedy.

Beyond Larry’s stellar work, there is also Lapid’s constantly seeking camera, following characters around at ground level, spotting the nuances and flavors of everyday lives that have seemingly been sapped of both. It is a film about art that is as cynical as Exit Through the Gift Shop but drained of satire. The Kindergarten Teacher is deadly serious.

When the film came out, Lapid called the titular teacher a “terrorist for art,” and she certainly proves willing to blow up her life, metaphorically, for the cause. As we slide further into a culture that ignores beauty for the banal, Lapid was already here on the front line before we knew there was a war, calling it a battle before the first shot was fired. It all seems so clear now, but The Kindergarten Teacher knew then.

See also: 99 Homes, when Andrew Garfield finally got to step away from the Spider-man mask that was always ill-fitted and show us once again the thespian underneath. Few films understood and conveyed the economic realities of the decade better than this vital Ramin Bahrani work.

Moana (2016)

Moana made $690 million worldwide. It was a critical hit. It featured a popular soundtrack spearheaded by the brilliant Lin-Manuel Miranda. And in its time across various streaming services, it has proved to be endlessly rewatchable. Despite all of this, it feels as though the film is destined to animated also-ran status for the 2010s.

The Frozen franchise was the biggest animated hit of a decade bookended by a pair of Toy Story sequels (Toy Story 3 in 2010 and Toy Story 4 in 2019), part of Pixar’s continued dominance in the animation realm. Hayao Miyazaki made his supposed swan song (The Wind Rises in 2013, though he may have further features yet to come). Spiderman: Into the Spider-Verse changed how we look at animation and animated heroes. This all went on, and still, I keep coming back to Moana.

I can’t think of a better animated story to save for future generations than that of a young Polynesian girl who takes control of her destiny, saves her people, and defeats a “villain” not with violence but empathy. It is classic Disney, presented in a way that is anything but classic. There is no princess. There is no prince. There is just a fearless warrior, who instead of urging us to let it go, asks us to wonder how far we’ll go.

See also: 20th Century Women, Mike Mills’ loving portrait of the women who raised him, which stands among the most empathetic films of a time in which empathy seems in short supply. Annette Bening, Greta Gerwig, and Elle Fanning are remarkable at the head of an ensemble of lives that feel truly lived.

In the Fade (2017)

Each of us is dealing in some way with forgiveness and reconciliation, be it on a small scale within ourselves or our families or on a grander scale with a society that continues to oppress and marginalize the most vulnerable among us. There is no easy answer, there is no quick fix, and no peace appears to be on the horizon. So, what are we left with? Fear. Anger. Resentment. Hatred. And a lack of avenues to explore and work through these feelings. In that spirit, director Fatih Akin’s In the Fade sure seems like the movie of the moment.

Despite winning the Golden Globe for best foreign language film and despite starring Diane Kruger, one of Germany’s most famous actresses internationally, who won best actress at the Cannes Film Festival for this performance, In the Fade was criminally underseen. Perhaps it was too raw for American audiences. Tell me if this sounds familiar: A person of color is killed, and the system spends its time investigating the deceased for reasons it is his fault he is dead. Throw in the true antagonists, a band of Neo Nazis, and though set in Germany, this begins to resemble the America a lot of us know today.

Kruger plays the wife of the Turkish man who is killed along with their son in a terrorist bombing, and when the system fails to achieve justice, she is left to face a world that would rather protect Nazis than avenge an immigrant. So, we return to forgiveness and reconciliation. The Christian bible says Jesus wants us to forgive 77 times – or maybe 70 times 7. In the Fade asks what of that next time and whether practicing forgiveness and reconciliation simply comforts evil-doers. What of and at what cost accountability? Akin’s answer comes not from the bible but another worldly scribe: Don’t let the sun go down on your grievances.

See also: The Florida Project, about mostly good people mostly trying to do good in a world that has little time or patience for small kindnesses. Writer-director Sean Baker’s film is equal parts damning and triumphant, portraying the American Dream as a flickering candle, a beacon of hope that at any moment could be extinguished.


Black Panther (2018)

Ryan Coogler dominated the decade. I say that as a plain fact. I am on the record all over this website calling Coogler the best director in the game today, and I have not seen a compelling argument for anyone else. He burst on to the scene in 2013 with Fruitvale Station, an underseen masterwork. From there, he took over one of the most storied franchises in American film and made it relevant again with Creed in 2015. Finally, to close out the decade, he gifted the world Black Panther.

For 2018, Black Panther simply was the culture. Think about how remarkable this is: A black man directs a script from two black writers (Coogler and Joe Robert Cole), starring a mostly black cast, and the film becomes the highest-grossing domestic box-office hit (until Avengers: Endgame took back the title) in a series that is otherwise painfully white. But leave aside for a moment everything the film means to the industry and the world at large, and what you are left with is a tremendous work of art and, for my money, the finest superhero film ever made.

Black Panther is great because as thrilling as its set pieces are, as cool as its technology is, as fun as its heroes are, it is a film equally concerned with ideas. Though it ends with a big fight sequence – as required by Marvel formula – the battle is about more than brawn. It is about ideas, about ideology. Coogler engages the audience intellectually in a way that even few non-superhero films have the courage to do. That he does so while entertaining so thoroughly makes Black Panther like watching a magic trick – and Coogler, right now, is the world’s greatest magician.

See also: The Other Side of the Wind, the final Orson Welles film, about which we do not talk enough, perhaps because we take for granted a masterpiece from one of the greatest directors ever to step behind a camera. It is the perfect coda to a sadly imperfect career, marred by a system that could not understand or appreciate the genius in its midst.

The Nightingale (2019)

Writer-director Jennifer Kent seemed to spring forth fully formed with her astonishing horror debut The Babadook in 2014. Her second feature, the equally horrific but decidedly less supernatural The Nightingale, proves that first film was no fluke and that Kent will be a filmmaker to be reckoned with in the coming decade.

A revenge thriller where the antagonist is nothing less than European colonialism, The Nightingale takes place 200 years ago and could not feel more of the moment. Our heroes are a white convict woman (Aisling Franciosi) and an aboriginal tracker (Baykali Ganambarr), who each have reasons to be angry with the hand life has dealt them, or more specifically, the hand their white male overseers have dealt them.

As they trek through the Tasmanian wilderness, doggedly pursuing those who have wronged them, we are confronted with the kinds of banal, everyday violence that make up life in a world destroyed by its conquerors. The film is brutal, bloody, and assaultive, all of which I mean as compliments, as Kent never shies from her duty to portray the truth of this place and these people. This is not about the nobility in the fight – there is no nobility or grace to be found here – but rather the necessity of struggle. No one wanted things to be this way, but they are, and we do what we must.

See also: Aquarela, which is the most beguiling and entrancing documentary to come along in quite some time, demonstrating the power of the natural world and, thereby, humanity’s inherent powerlessness. We are guests here, and not permanent ones at that.

___

Thursday, March 7, 2019

New movie review: Woman at War



It can be easy to forget why the fight matters. Saving the earth from the destruction mankind has wrought is a goal that is equal parts grand and abstract. It is certain our survival depends on the fate of a planet that sure as hell did not need us before we got here but desperately needs us now. But what that means in real terms can start to blur around the edges.

Then you look in the eyes of a 4-year-old girl who has lost her family to war. Her face is pleading but resilient as she holds out a small bouquet. A photo of this girl provides the emotional through-line of Woman at War, the new film from Icelandic director Benedikt Erlingsson, which carries on that rich Scandinavian tradition of placing human comedy and human tragedy right alongside each other.

Halldóra Geirharðsdóttir stars as Halla, a choir director in her late 40s or early 50s who has dedicated her off hours to sabotaging Iceland’s smelting industry through direct attacks on its power grid. She is mild-mannered and sweet in her work but brave and determined in her battle, these two sides co-existing within her without irony or contradiction. She is all of these and more and always believably thanks to a fabulous performance by Geirharðsdóttir and a perfectly pitched script co-written by Erlingsson with Ólafur Egilsson.

Halla’s mission is thrown into jeopardy when she receives word an application for adoption she filed long ago – long before beginning her dangerous but vital work – has been approved. She will be mother to Nika, a 4-year-old Ukrainian girl whose parents died in the war and who was discovered with the body of her grandmother, who had been dead for days. She receives the photograph of this small child, alone in the world, and her dilemma is clear.

If Halla continues on her path, she is likely to be caught and thrown in jail, leaving Nika without a mother. At the same time, who is this struggle for if not for Nika? Saving the planet is necessary, yes, but that is the abstract. The specifics are to preserve a habitable home for children like Nika and to prevent the next generation from having to pay the bill for our mistakes. In this light, we see that Halla holds the future of not just one child in her hands, but all children.

The filmmaking throughout is superb, particularly during the thrilling sabotage sequences. Erlingsson makes wonderful use of Iceland’s natural beauty by often framing Geirharðsdóttir alone against vast, verdant fields and a steely gray sky. It is a high-stakes cat-and-mouse game, and Erlingsson milks the suspense for all it is worth. But whimsical flourishes like putting the musicians and singers providing the film’s score right on screen – not to be commented upon as part of the action but there like a record player might be – ensure the drama never becomes self-serious nor the message too heavy-handed.

The script is smart about the way politicians and industry leaders try to spin the climate debate in the press, portraying environmentalism as inherently anti-business and attempting to turn public sentiment against Halla and her quest. There are also some shenanigans with twins, cousins, and a luckless Mexican tourist, but all of this is spice. They provide depth and flavor to the film, but the true meal, the core of the story, is Halla’s responsibility to her future daughter and the future world.

The ending briefly looks as if it will be a little too tidy before closing on a confidently ambiguous and beautifully conceived final shot that ties all of the story’s thematic threads together. The destruction we have rendered is already upon us, it argues. We are knee-deep in it. There is nothing else we can do but forge ahead bravely, holding close and protecting that which matters most.

Wednesday, February 13, 2019

Countdown to the Oscars: What you can see




In past years, we have gone category by category when looking at the Academy Awards nominees, which was a fun but exhausting exercise for yours truly. This year, if you will allow, I would like to try something a little different: grouping the nominees by theme and examining them together.

To kick this off, I thought we would start with the crafts categories that make their presence known onscreen – in other words, what you can see.

In keeping with tradition, we will take a look at what nominee is likely to walk away with the win on Oscars night, what I would award, and what in a perfect world I would have liked to see on the shortlist.

It neither should escape our attention the Academy has announced the four categories it will not air live during the broadcast of the awards ceremony. Among them are Best Cinematography and Best Editing, to go with Best Makeup and Hairstyling and Best Live Action Short. You will note three of these categories discussed below, and while the entire affair is a travesty, the exclusion of Cinematography and Editing is particularly galling.

Roma director Alfonso Cuarón and reigning Best Director Guillermo del Toro have already weighed in with their displeasure, among many others, including the American Society of Cinematographers guild. ABC and the Academy seem unlike to waver on this point at this late date, so close to the show as we are, but here’s hoping a revolt among nominees – it would have to be led by the actors – can help correct this egregious error.

Best Cinematography


Nominees: Cold War; The Favourite; Never Look Away; Roma; A Star Is Born

Speaking of Cuarón, the director is the odds-on favorite to walk away with the prize here. He would be the first person to win for lensing a film he also directed. His guiding principle, he has said, was “What would Chivo do?” – a reference to longtime friend and collaborator Emmanuel Lubezski. Apart from the gorgeous lighting and lengthy tracking shots, a staple of Lubezski and Cuarón’s work together, Cuarón looks to be taking from Page 1 of the Chivo playbook: Win the Oscar. Lubezski is the only person to win this award three times in a row, taking home the award for Gravity (also directed by Cuarón), Birdman and The Revenant. Now his friend could be following in his footsteps.

The monkey wrench could be Cold War director of photography Lukasz Zal, who won the ASC guild award, though that could have been a group of cinematographers voting for one of their own over an outsider director. Zal’s square-framed, black-and-white work on Pawel Pawlikowsi’s daring romance would not be unworthy. My choice is probably running third here, Robbie Ryan’s daft, iconoclastic work on The Favourite, while six-time nominee Caleb Deschanel (Never Look Away) and twice-nominated Matthew Libatique (A Star Is Born) are probably also-rans, who both were surprise nominees to one degree or another.

This likely comes down to Roma vs. Cold War, and I expect the Academy as a whole will be less reluctant than the cinematographers to reward Cuarón for his lovely work.

Will win: Roma
Should win: The Favourite
Should have been here: First Man

Best Editing


Nominees: BlacKkKlansman; Bohemian Rhapsody; The Favourite; Green Book; Vice

An eclectic group to say the least, here we find a police procedural, a music biopic, a costume drama, a serio-comic road movie, and a political satire. The only thing missing is a war movie and we would have Best Editing BINGO.

Patrick J. Don Vito (Green Book) and Yorgos Mavropsaridis (The Favourite) do the least-flashy work here, though The Favourite features some spectacular dissolves, particularly during its end sequence. If Green Book maintains its cooling Best Picture heat, it is possible Don Vito scores here, but that is less likely by the day. Meanwhile, Barry Alexander Brown provides BlacKkKlansman with the kind of tight, crisp editing thrillers thrive on, and if the film picks up steam, he could be one to watch (or not, as again, this award will be presented during a commercial break).

In my estimation, however, it comes down to John Ottman for Bohemian Rhapsody and Hank Corwin for Vice. Both films traverse an expansive amount of time, incorporating flashbacks and flash forwards, and each is a feat of continuity. Corwin was previously nominated for The Big Short, while this is the first nomination for Ottman, who is the usual editor for disgraced director Bryan Singer, though Singer’s crimes should not be held against Ottman.

Many in the punditry are predicting a win for Vice here, but I do not see it. While that film’s buzz has cooled off the closer we have gotten to the ceremony, Bohemian Rhapsody remains at the forefront of the conversation amid a DVD release this week and lead actor Rami Malek’s ever-presence on the awards circuit. With all the whip-cracking cuts to the copious music and elegant blending of concert and studio footage, I will back Ottman’s work on the Queen biopic.

Will win: Bohemian Rhapsody
Should win: BlacKkKlansman
Should have been here: First Man

Best Production Design


Nominees: Black Panther; The Favourite; First Man; Mary Poppins Returns; Roma

Four period pieces and a fantasy, here is a group that is not exactly stepping outside its wheelhouse. At the same time, these nominees are as different as they are impressive, each bringing to vivid life the worlds they are eager to depict.

Fiona Crombie’s and Alice Felton’s work on The Favourite is the most traditional nominee among these, as a period piece set in the halls of British royalty, and it may very well be our winner. It would be hard to deny the film is a sumptuous feast for the eyes, though its most slam-dunk proposition may be the next category down.

Eugenio Cabellero and Barbara Enriquez recreated entire blocks of Mexico City for Roma, bringing a richness of detail and truth to the proceedings, while Nathan Crowley and Kathy Lucas brought the Apollo missions to life in First Man for a generation that barely remembers a time before “One small step.” John Myhre and Gordon Sim created a delightful world for Mary Poppins Returns, though the lengthy animated sequence at the film’s center may confuse the point for some voters.

Finally, Hannah Beachler and Jay Hart made the Wakanda of Black Panther a real place, as futuristic and fantastical as it may seem. It should also be said Beachler is the first African American to be nominated in this category, which should be considered an honor for her and a glaring oversight throughout the years by the Academy.

If you are asking me for a prediction, go with the clearly popular, heavily nominated period piece set mostly in the big, fancy castle, but watch out for a Black Panther-sized upset.

Will win: The Favourite
Should win: The Favourite
Should have been here: The Death of Stalin

Best Costume Design


Nominees: The Ballad of Buster Scruggs; Black Panther; The Favourite; Mary Poppins Returns; Mary Queen of Scots

Even more beholden to period work than the production designers, the costumers did not even bother nominating a worthy contemporary film such as Crazy Rich Asians. But if La La Land, which lost this award to Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them two years ago, could not break the stranglehold – no contemporary film has won since The Adventures of Priscilla, Queen of the Desert in 1993 (1994 ceremony) – this wasn’t going to be the year.

Academy favorite Sandy Powell (14 nominations, three wins) is a double nominee this year for The Favourite and Mary Poppins Returns, which also happen to be the two best designed films of the year. Don’t expect Powell to split her vote, as Academy members are likely to rally behind The Favourite and give it the deserved win here.

Alexandra Byrne’s costumes for Mary Queen of Scots are wading in the same territory as The Favourite but for the far less-acclaimed film. Mary Zophres’ The Ballad of Buster Scruggs is a bit of an outsider nominee, though not Zophres herself. She was previously nominated for the above-mentioned La La Land and the Coen Brothers’ other pure western, True Grit.

The spoiler could be Ruth E. Carter’s stunning Afro-futurist designs for Black Panther. Expect to read that a lot in this space, as Black Panther is a threat anywhere it is nominated, up to and including the big award. All it had to do was get to the dance, and the work will speak for itself.

Still, old habits die hard and Powell is a deserving and likely winner for the crazed, distressed rags of a monarchy in decline.

Will win: The Favourite
Should win: The Favourite
Should have been here: BlacKkKlansman

Best Makeup and Hairstyling


Nominees: Border; Mary Queen of Scots; Vice

It is a fascinating quirk of processes like these when for the third time in four years, an obscure (to Americans, at least) Swedish film is nominated in this category. The previous two times, it was the team of Love Larson and Eva von Bahr for The 100-year-old Man Who Climbed Out the Window and Disappeared and A Man Called Ove. This time around, we have Göran Lundström and Pamela Goldammer for the strange and hypnotic Border. Like their countrymen, this team is the least likely winner, simply for the low profile of the film, but the work is tremendous and there is clearly something going right in the Swedish makeup and hairstyling community.

One need only look at the posters and other promotional materials to understand how Jenny Shircore, Marc Pilcher, and Jessica Brooks landed here for Mary Queen of Scots. The work on Margot Robbie alone likely would have been enough to score the nomination – though I actually found the prosthetic nose Robbie wore distracting. The film, however, is not held in high regard, and while their fellow craftsmen were always a strong bet to recognize this team, the Academy at large is less so.

That leaves Vice, the Best Picture nominee featuring showy prosthetics and hairstyling work throughout, supplementing another of Christian Bale’s miraculous – and disgusting, if you ask my wife – physical transformations. It has been written in this space before, but when there is a lone Best Picture nominee among this group, that is your winner almost every time. The last time that logic did not hold was 1997, when Titanic lost to Men in Black. Men in Black, however, was a showy, popular blockbuster. Vice faces no such competition.

Will win: Vice
Should win: Vice
Should have been here: Suspiria

Best Visual Effects


Nominees: Avengers: Infinity War; Christopher Robin; First Man; Ready Player One; Solo: A Stars Wars Story

Boy, the industry really held those kinda-funky rhinos against Black Panther this season. After the visual effects society most shied away from the Best Picture-nominated blockbuster, the Academy’s visual effects branch went a step further and failed even to nominate it. The snub seems a bit extreme when so much of the rest of the film was so brilliantly rendered, but here we are.

Avengers: Infinity War is holding down the Marvel Cinematic Universe spot this year, and while the MCU has been well represented among the past nominees, no Marvel film has won this award – not counting Sam Raimi’s Spider-Man 2, which won in 2002, prior to the rise of the modern Marvel universe. This year, however, it feels as though Avengers: Infinity War is likely to win almost by default.

Solo: A Star Wars Story was always a good bet for a nomination, considering every Star Wars film but Episode III has been named in this category. The nominating committee clearly likes these films, but the Academy has cooled to them, and no film outside the original trilogy has taken home gold here. The least acclaimed of the new-generation Star Wars films is unlikely to break that streak.

Steven Spielberg’s not-well-loved Ready Player One adaptation certainly features a lot of effects work, but to my eyes, much of it was dingy and unpleasant. First Man would be a deserving winner, but one fears its effects are too seamlessly integrated into the film to be noticed for their wonder – an ironic fate, to be sure. Meanwhile, Christopher Robin’s fuzzy Hundred Acre Wood residents are brought to life with all the charm one would hope for. I cannot let the moment pass without saying the film is an unmitigated joy, a nostalgia-inducing pleasure from beginning to end, though that will do nothing to carry it to the win.

Unless we are looking at another year as strange as that time Ex Machina swooped in and snatched this award, it appears Marvel will finally find the winner’s circle. Of course, none of these would be as shocking as that Ex Machina victory, which remains unlikely to be topped in that regard.

Will win: Avengers: Infinity War
Should win: First Man
Should have been here: Black Panther

Next time on the Countdown to the Oscars, we tackle What You Can Hear.

Sunday, February 10, 2019

Countdown to the Oscars: Welcome to 2019



Time for a confession that won’t come as a shock to anyone who has followed the site: I am a longtime Academy apologist. If you have read my reviews of past Oscar ceremonies, you know this. If you have listened to me argue for Crash as the superior film to Brokeback Mountain, you know this – though I would argue Capote was that year’s best nominated film. I enjoyed the ceremony where Anne Hathaway tried her best to host with a high-out-of-his-mind James Franco, fully understanding my friends and I might be the only ones.

The Oscars ceremony is an event I look forward to all year, every year. It is not an exaggeration to say my calendar year revolves more around the Academy Awards than New Year’s Day. I say all this so you will understand it is out of deep love that I say this: Bluntly, I fear this year’s ceremony will suck. I don’t know that there is a better, more elegant way to put it. Sometimes, simple is best, and simply, this year might suck.

The Academy and its host network, Disney-owned (isn’t everything?) ABC have tripped all over themselves throughout this awards cycle, making mistake after mistake, correcting some, leaving others, until the ceremony they are proposing has begun to sound not like a classical celebration of movies but a grinding chore.

Let’s take a look at some of what’s gone on so far:

The Best Popular Film category: This was a clear disaster from the start. Before we get into it, let’s keep in mind that the driving force behind all of this is ratings. Ratings equal money, and there is no decision that has been announced, at least initially, that is not brutally aware of the bottom line. Of course, we all know how well bottom-line thinking and art co-exist.

Clearly, this attempt at broadening the variety of films nominated was aimed at including blockbusters like Black Panther, which of course is a popcorn masterpiece that was recognized in the top category on merit. The thinking goes: Blockbusters equal viewers because people will tune in to see movies they know about and enjoyed. Supporters of this theory will point to years like 1997 (1998 ceremony), when Titanic won Best Picture and the awards received their highest viewership ever.

This is a juicy premise, and it is understandable why the money men and women would choose to believe it, but it does not hold up to scrutiny. The Titanic ceremony drew 55.25 million viewers, the most ever, but the most watched ceremony by audience percentage was in 1970, when Midnight Cowboy – the X-rated drama about a gigolo, which no one would confuse with a blockbuster – won the top award.

The telecast numbers have gone down every year since 2014, five years of declining ratings resulting in last year’s show being the least watched ever. The Best Picture winner: The Shape of Water, a weird Cold War fish-sex romantic drama, which happened also to be the best film of the year. Perhaps understandable that no one tuned in for that? But keep in mind, box-office-wise, The Shape of Water outperformed every Best Picture winner since the downturn began.

The Academy and ABC are under the misconception that the nominated films somehow are keeping people away. They are not. Let me suggest the obvious – meaning I will not have been the first to say this. It is simply choice. When Titanic was named Best Picture of the year in 1998, 55 million people tuned in because what else were they going to watch. Hell, The Sopranos had not even debuted. Last year, roughly 26 million people watched, nearly half of the Titanic numbers. That looks bad, but in a different light, that represents half as many viewers who had 100 times the choice.

No single similar event but the Super Bowl (which, by the way, suffered dramatically reduced viewership this year) will ever draw 55 million viewers again. It just doesn’t happen in an era when there are 800 channels to watch and infinite streaming options.

The hosting debacle: Let’s say this right off – Kevin Hart would have been a fine host, in the vein of a Jimmy Kimmel, Jon Stewart, or Chris Rock. He would not have been blatantly offensive like Seth McFarlane, and he would not have been overly milquetoast like Ellen DeGeneres or Neil Patrick Harris, both whose hosting gigs I genuinely enjoyed. He likely would have hit the sweet spot in his opening monologue of pointed political humor and general inside-Hollywood jocularity. It would have been fine.

That said, I cannot fault anyone for their reactions to his past homophobic material, and Hart did not help himself with his half-hearted non-apologies. The Academy then suffered the unfortunate look of no one wanting to host the show, which has led to a host-less ceremony, the first of its kind since 1989, when 42 million people tuned in to watch Rain Man win Best Picture. That is roughly equivalent to the 42 million who watched Rock host in 2005 (Million Dollar Baby) and the 43.7 million who watched DeGeneres host in 2014 (12 Years a Slave), the highest-rated ceremony of the new century.

A good host is a bonus. He or she makes the ceremony more fun, more enjoyable, perhaps more whimsical. It is not, however, a make-or-break proposition. No one tunes in to see the host, which is among the most thankless jobs in Hollywood. No one ever likes the show, so you do your best, you try to have fun, then you try to forget about it. This should not have mattered as much as it did, but welcome to the modern era.

The tyranny of the three-hour show: This is ABC’s latest scourge, which has been evident in all of its decision-making and was painfully obvious at the normally loose and fun Academy Awards luncheon, where producer Donna Gigliotti stressed repeatedly the importance of keeping speeches short and getting the ceremony in in under three hours.

As we discuss this, keep in mind the longest Academy Awards on record came in 2002, when A Beautiful Mind was named Best Picture. The show lasted four hours and 23 minutes. The number of viewers: 40.5 million. Don’t let anyone tell you length matters to the viewer, or more specifically, the viewership numbers.

This myth that a three-hour show will help revive viewership has led to all of the worst ideas to come out of this year’s proposed ceremony: the plan to perform just two of the five Best Original Song nominees (corrected by virtue of nominee solidarity); the limiting of speech time to 90 seconds, including walk time; and most offensive of all, the shunting off to commercial breaks those categories that might be considered less sexy or viewer friendly.

I must believe – for sanity’s sake if nothing else – that these ideas were proposed by ABC. Otherwise, I would have to reconcile the idea that Academy has no idea what it is or what makes its show tick.

Limiting the songs to two is such a jaw-dropping idea one wonders how it could ever have been pitched. Some of the show’s best moments come from those songs – Common and John Legend’s performance of “Glory” from Selma is a watershed moment in Academy history. The nominees rightfully revolted, and we will have a full complement of songs – if shortened and bastardized to fit into a pre-determined window of time.

On speech length – counting walking time is by far the pettiest thing the producers can do to cut down on show runtime – let’s do some math. With 24 categories, at 90 seconds each, that is 36 minutes of speeches. With the allotted – and ludicrous – seven minutes to perform five original songs, that is 42 minutes of show. Say – and this is a rough estimate – they have to fill two hours and 10 minutes, with 50 minutes of commercials in their dream three-hour show. What you are left with is 88 minutes of host-less banter between awards speeches.

Throw in the In Memorium sequence and we have roughly 80 minutes of free-flowing, unmoored nonsense. This is the Oscars. It is about the winners. Any other belief is misguided and wrong-headed. The speeches are why one tunes in. We do not need to see comedians and actors and the like performing stilted “witty” conversations in lieu of the honest emotion of an artist reacting to the most important moment of his or her life.

Which brings us to the idea of hiding certain categories during the commercial break – rumored to be five or six categories with no word on which as of yet. The very idea is disgusting, and the Academy should be ashamed for allowing such an idea to make it out of a brainstorm – and for not firing the person who brainstormed it.

The Oscars are about celebrating movie-making, and there is not one person nominated in any category who is less important than another in the art of filmmaking. The show is supposed to be about giving them their moment in the sun. Not to do so is a betrayal of what the Academy Awards stand for.

I know it is all about commerce, and the show is essentially one big commercial for the movie industry. Love us, buy tickets, see movies. I get that. But at the same time, when the legendary Roger Deakins wins Best Cinematography on his 14th nomination, that is a moment to cherish. When a documentary filmmaker calls out the presidential administration for its lies and falsehoods, that is a moment. The show is about moments, and the artists are the ones who give us those moments. And that means all the artists, not just the ones whose faces we recognize.

How to fix the Oscars

This year’s ceremony cannot be saved. We are in an expect-the-worst, hope-for-the-best scenario already. But what can be done in the future? I would make a single change that would address all of the current demons haunting the Academy Awards.

Make it pay-per-view.

The dwindling numbers are evidence that given the preponderance of entertainment options – be they on TV, the internet, your phone, or some combination of all of these – only hard-core fans are going to watch the ceremony. This is fine. In fact, in the age of new media, it is ideal. It is impossible to survive by trying to be all things to all people. By attempting to pull this off, the Academy is not drawing in new viewers, but it is alienating its core viewers. With an entire media world at everyone’s fingertips, it is important to fill a niche. The Oscars are a perfectly constructed niche. Those who desire to watch will pay – a la carte viewership is the current wave of television consumption anyway.

In addition, by divorcing itself of a network and of corporate demands, the Academy is free to be its true self. This will be offputting to some – even I, a fan, would describe that true self as elitist, leftist, and self-congratulatory – but they would not watch to begin with. Instead, the Academy would be free to form a deeper connection with those it appeals to most. This creates loyalty and repeat viewership.

As far as the actual effect on the show, as we said, length is not a problem for viewers who care to watch in the first place. Moreover, on pay-per-view, commercial breaks are eliminated. For breaks when those in attendance – or those at home – might want to hit the bar, visit the bathroom, or just mingle, there are the montages the Academy loves so much each year. But now, instead of taking up valuable network airtime, they are the breaks in action, entertaining but disposable and perfectly suited to this function.

Ironically, this elimination of commercial breaks would naturally bring the length of the show down to three hours or less, but of course, that is not something the pay-per-viewers would care about. However, perhaps the show could move to Saturday night, when the pay-per-view could air live the entirety of the ceremony. Then, a network could buy the rights to an edited version of the ceremony to air later the same night or the next night – the traditional Sunday. This increases revenue and decreases running time.

Of course, by airing a tape-delayed version the next night, everyone will already know the winners, but the primary function of the show at that point would simply be as a piece of entertainment. With countless big-name stars, big musical numbers from the Original Song nominees, and a smart opening with a talented, funny host, it would be the best show on TV and would still draw the 25 million or so viewers who are watching anyway.

***

So, there it is. I am only a fan, and maybe I am way off base – but certainly no more than the Academy and ABC. I look forward to Oscars night every year, but this is the first year a sense of dread has crept into the equation. If the Academy cannot figure out what makes those who love it and follow it want to love and follow, it will die. And that would be a shame.

Welcome to Last Cinema Standing’s Countdown to the Oscars, which will proceed a little differently this year. Keep checking back here at the site for more analysis and discussion of the year’s Academy Award-nominated films.

Tuesday, January 22, 2019

Roma, The Favourite top nominees for 91st Academy Awards

Roma


The Academy, so reluctant in recent years to embrace Netflix and the streaming revolution in general, has kicked that bad habit cold turkey this year with massive support for Alfonso Cuarón’s masterful Roma.

Nominees for the 91st Academy Awards were announced early Tuesday morning, and Roma led the way with 10, tied with Yorgos Lanthimos’ royal comedy The Favourite. A Star Is Born and Vice each picked up eight nominations, while Ryan Coogler’s powerful superhero epic Black Panther garnered seven.

All five of those films earned Best Picture nominations and are joined in the top category by BlacKkKlansman (six nominations), Bohemian Rhapsody (five), and Green Book (five).

Roma had been expected to be among the leaders and picked up expected nominations for Director, Cinematography, Sound Editing, and Sound Mixing but showed its true strength with well-deserved nominations for Yalitza Aparicio in Best Actress and Marina de Tavira in Best Supporting Actress. It also picked up nods for Production Design, Original Screenplay, and of course Foreign Language Film.

All of that means Cuarón is in position to walk away with five Academy Awards on the big night, as he served as writer, director, producer, and cinematographer on Roma. His name would also be on the statue in the Foreign Language category. He missed out on a sixth potential nomination when the film was surprisingly passed over for Best Editing, a category often seen as a bellwether for Best Picture.

Lanthimos, who had missed out with the Directors Guild, earned his first nomination for Best Director – a development that delights me to no end – and his wonderfully daft film showed up everywhere it conceivably could have. Its stars, Olivia Colman (Actress), Emma Stone (Supporting Actress), and Rachel Weisz (Supporting Actress) all picked up nominations, and though I would have liked to see all three in the leading category, I won’t argue with the recognition. The gorgeously mounted film was also named in Editing, Cinematography, Production Design, Costume Design, and Original Screenplay.

Filling out the Best Director category are Pawel Pawlikowski for Cold War, which also picked up a Cinematography nod and joined Roma among the Foreign Language nominees, Adam McKay for Vice, and Spike Lee with his long-overdue first directing nomination for BlacKkKlansman. That left Peter Farrelly (Green Book) and most shockingly Bradley Cooper (A Star Is Born) on the outside looking in, although both picked up other nominations – Farrelly for Original Screenplay and Cooper for Best Actor.

Coogler sadly did not make the final five for his work elevating the superhero genre to new heights, but the film’s stellar showing is evidence the Academy can embrace a Marvel blockbuster when it’s done right. Coogler, of course, knows how to do it right. In addition to Best Picture, Black Panther was cited for Costume Design, Production Design, Sound Editing, Sound Mixing, Original Score, and Original Song. It was not included among the Visual Effects nominees, where Avengers: Infinity War will carry the Marvel banner.

Joining Cooper on the Best Actor list are Rami Malek (Bohemian Rhapsody), Christian Bale (Vice), Viggo Mortenson (Green Book), and Willem Dafoe (At Eternity’s Gate). Aparicio and Colman will compete for Best Actress with Glenn Close (The Wife), Lady Gaga (A Star Is Born), and Melissa McCarthy (Can You Ever Forgive Me?).

The Supporting Actor category features Adam Driver (BlacKkKlansman), Sam Elliott (A Star Is Born), Mahershala Ali (Green Book), Richard E. Grant (Can You Ever Forgive Me?), and Sam Rockwell (Vice). Amy Adams (Vice) and Regina King (If Beale Street Could Talk) round out the Supporting Actress category with Stone, Weisz, and de Tavira.

It is traditional for film lovers and Oscar watchers to spend the rest of nominations morning grousing about the movies and performances that were not nominated, but on a celebratory day such as this, I like to keep positivity on the menu.

In that spirit, I shall dispense with small gripes as quickly as possible. I wish Ethan Hawke and Amanda Seyfried had found more appreciation for their work in First Reformed. While Mary Poppins Returns pulled down four nominations (Score, Song, Costume Design, and Production Design), it would have been nice to see Emily Blunt recognized for finding her own take on the titular character and Rob Marshall cited for his fluid and fanciful direction. Other minor quibbles can be saved for another day.

In the plus column – and the plus far outweighs the minus today – I am overjoyed by the showings of both The Favourite and Roma, for my money the two best films of the year. Lanthimos’ and Lee’s directing nominations are music to my ears. Also, it is about time Paul Schrader gets some love from the Academy with an Original Screenplay nod that by no means should be his first but somehow is.

This might be my favorite Costume Design group in a long while, featuring the double Sandy Powell nomination (The Favourite and Mary Poppins Returns) and the out-of-this world Ruth Carter designs on Black Panther. Excited to see Bing Liu’s Minding the Gap in Documentary for the kind of long-form character study Liu’s mentor, Steve James, usually gets overlooked for. And finally, bravo for Hirozaku Kore-eda’s Shoplifters making the final five for Foreign Language.

That’s all for now folks. Click here for the full list of nominees, and check back on the site over the next month for more about these awards and these great films.