Showing posts with label Best Animated Short. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Best Animated Short. Show all posts

Sunday, March 2, 2025

2024 Academy Awards Category Breakdown: The Shorts


I present a truncated version of my usual in-depth category breakdowns. Here are the three shorts categories:


Documentary Short

Nominees

Death by Numbers

I Am Ready, Warden

Incident

Instruments of a Beating Heart

The Only Girl in the Orchestra


Incident is one of the most devastating, powerful, and infuriating short films in recent memory. It shows every possible angle of a police shooting while offering a rarely seen insight into the minds of the officers who perpetrate these crimes in real time. It’s a scathing indictment of our justice system and proof of what most of us knew or suspected. The question now: What are we prepared to do about it?


If Incident is a little too formally radical, with its lack of voiceover, talking-head interviews, or traditional structure, two other films in the lineup tackle similarly pressing issues with a more conventional style. I Am Ready, Warden tells the dual narrative of a convict on death row and the son of the man he murdered as both await the convict’s execution. It’s gripping viewing and visceral evidence of the fact that there are no winners in capital punishment.


Death by Numbers comes at capital punishment from a different angle: the point of view of a school shooting survivor testifying at the sentencing hearing for the murderer. This is an interesting pairing with I Am Ready, Warden, given this film’s framing around a hoped-for death sentence. I found much of Death by Numbers a little shallow and lacking in perspective, which is disappointing for a film about one of our nation’s most devastating crises.


Instruments of a Beating Heart and The Only Girl in the Orchestra are two very different musical documentaries, both quietly delightful in their own ways. It should not go unmentioned that another musical doc short won this category last year – The Last Repair Shop – but neither of these has that film’s artistry or thematic depth.


For the win, Incident may be just too darn experimental for these voters, and since they can give the award to something more easily digestible and still feel like they’re standing up for a cause, expect that to be the case. While a Death by Numbers win would not be shocking, I Am Ready, Warden packs the greater punch, so that’s the pick.


Will win: I Am Ready, Warden

Should win: Incident


Animated Short

Nominees

Beautiful Men

In the Shadow of the Cypress

Magic Candies

Wander to Wonder

Yuck!


I found myself a little underwhelmed by the Animated Short selections this year. In past years, this category has been loaded with bold, brilliant visions that push the boundaries of both animation and storytelling. Recent films like last year’s An Ostrich Told Me the World Was Fake and I Think I Believe It, 2020’s Opera, and 2014’s The Dam Keeper showcase the best of what these shorts can do. This year, only one of these five lived up to that standard.


Wander to Wonder is the front-runner almost by default. It won the Annie and the BAFTA in this category. It’s a beautifully rendered stop-motion piece that tells a story of breaking free from the strictures of the lives we believe we must lead. The animation is key to the execution. It’s funny, surprising, and ultimately inspiring. Would that there were four more of these in the lineup.


Beautiful Men, about three bald brothers at a hair-restoration clinic, comes the closest but ultimately is a little too slight. Yuck! and Magic Candies are both sweet stories of children learning about the world around them. And, if I’m being honest, I found In the Shadow of the Cypress a little impenetrable. It looks good, but I couldn’t make heads or tails of it.


Will win: Wander to Wonder

Should win: Wander to Wonder


Live-Action Short

Nominees

A Lien

Anuja

I’m Not a Robot

The Last Ranger

The Man Who Could Not Remain Silent


This is an excellent slate of nominees, and even the least among them is an endearingly strange ride with more to say than it perhaps first appears. Let’s just do a brief survey of the topics covered by these five shorts: the extra-legal deportation of immigrants from this country; the limited options afforded to children trapped in India’s class structure; our AI future and its moral and ethical implications; rhino poaching in South Africa; and a true story of heroism amid an ethnic cleansing in ‘90s Croatia.


I would say A Lien has the inside track to the win here, given its urgent relevance to the current political situation in this country. It operates like a ticking-clock thriller as a family fights to avoid a trap set by ICE in which the agency explicitly promises a chance at a green card while hoping to lure and round up the most vulnerable among us. A title card at the end of the film tells us this is a true practice used by ICE. This is hardly surprising but no less infuriating.


The Last Ranger is a gorgeously photographed ode to the people who put their lives at risk in South Africa to prevent animal poachers from carrying out their awful work. I thought this was an excellent film – well written, well acted, and wonderfully constructed. 


Another tribute to a fallen hero, The Man Who Could Not Remain Silent tells the story of Tomo Buzov, who stood up to call out the injustice of a massacre and was himself brutally killed as a result. The filmmaking is brilliant in the way it puts you on the train with Buzov, not in his shoes but rather those of an observer, challenging you to consider whether you would stand up for what’s right under these circumstances. Tragically, Buzov’s son died just yesterday.


Anuja is a sweet story about a pre-teen girl working in a sweatshop in India who has an opportunity to take a scholarship at a boarding school but doesn’t want to leave her sister. It’s a nice little movie, but it lacks an ending. From a voting standpoint, the big thing in its favor is producer Mindy Kaling. It never hurts to have a big Hollywood celeb on your side in the shorts categories.


Finally, I’m Not a Robot takes a fascinating and comically absurd premise and stretches it out to its darkly logical conclusion. I won’t spoil any of the film’s surprises here, but suffice it to say, it presents a reality that feels just a step or two away from where we find ourselves now.


Will win: A Lien

Should win: A Lien

Saturday, March 2, 2024

Countdown to the Oscars: Best Animated Short


Welcome to this year’s edition of Last Cinema Standing’s Countdown to the Oscars, where we will break down each of the 23 categories, analyze the films, and make some guesses at their awards prospects.


Best Animated Short


The nominees are:


Letter to a Pig

Ninety-Five Senses

Our Uniform

Pachyderme

WAR IS OVER! Inspired by the Music of John & Yoko


Letter to a Pig

This is a fascinating film rendered in an absolutely stunning hand-drawn animation style. It started to lose me toward the back half as a dream logic took over the narrative and everything tipped into overly oblique abstraction, but that hardly takes away from the power of the overall story. Tal Kantor’s short centers on a Holocaust survivor telling his story to a classroom of preteens and the various reactions of the kids. It’s about as unique a take on generational trauma as you are likely to see, and though its message felt muddled, there is merit in the feelings this film evokes.


Ninety-Five Senses

Here’s a sentence I could never have predicted I would write: From Jared and Jerusha Hess, the husband-and-wife duo behind Napoleon Dynamite and Nacho Libre, we have a short animated film about capital punishment. That’s probably an unfairly glib way to put it. Ninety-FIve Senses is charming and witty in the way of much of their previous work and builds its power through the slow reveal of its true narrative intent. Using different animation styles to represent each of the five senses, as reflected on by an inmate awaiting a death sentence, this is a smart, impressive little short from two of the last people I would have expected.


Our Uniform

Based purely on animation style, this film was the most interesting of the bunch, using the fabric of clothing as a medium to tell the story of Iranian schoolgirls forced to dress in the most restrictive uniforms imaginable. There is perhaps too much restraint shown by director Yegane Moghaddam in the storytelling, but her point is well made. The film walks a fine line in attempting not to criticize a cultural and religious practice while also arguing that freedom of choice should be a part of any healthy society.


Pachyderme

A heartbreaking tale of child abuse and buried trauma, Stéphanie Clément’s short is the most powerful film of the bunch and the most gorgeous. Blending 2D and 3D animation, Clément crafts a disquieting atmosphere that leaves the viewer with a constant sense of unease. The images are beautiful, but in their framing and presentation, we sense that something is not right here. The story is impressionistic and dreamlike, in the way that childhood memories often are, and by the end, Clément has given us the tools to imagine a pain that borders on the unimaginable.


WAR IS OVER! Inspired by the Music of John & Yoko

I’m not typing out all of that every time. Boy, this film sure does have its heart in the right place. It’s also tremendously hokey, and if I’m being perfectly frank, I found the animation hideous. A lot of very talented people got behind this project to help push it over the finish line.


Peter Jackson, who seems to have a second career as champion of all things Beatles, produced and offered up the services of his Wētā FX to create the animation and visual effects. Director Dave Mullins is a former Pixar guy, who was previously nominated in this category for the clever Lou. Sean Ono Lennon co-wrote the script with Mullins and served as executive producer along with Yoko Ono. Hell, 15-time Academy Award nominee Thomas Newman did the score.


All of these brilliant artists came together to say, definitively, “War is bad. Peace is good.” I agree, but I didn’t need this movie to tell me that.


The final analysis


The category feels pretty wide open this year. Our Uniform is probably running in last place, through no fault of its own. Pachyderme may be too bleak to win over a plurality of voters. I could absolutely see any of the other three taking this award. WAR IS OVER! is probably the safe pick, given the pedigree of the people involved. It would be a mistake to sleep on Ninety-Five Senses as a potential spoiler here, given that film’s sneaky emotional resonance, but at the end of the day, Peter Jackson has employed a lot of people in this town. Sometimes, that’s all it takes.


Will win: WAR IS OVER! Inspired by the Music of John & Yoko

Should win: Pachyderme

Should have been here: Wild Summon


A note about my favorite snub: What if salmon were people, this film dares to ask. The answer to that question results in a short that is part nature documentary and part body horror. Directors Karni Arieli and Saul Freed blend live action footage of rivers and streams in Iceland with computer-animated human-fish things to demonstrate the harmful effects of overfishing and pollution on the natural world. It’s incredibly effective and not just a little freaky.

Monday, March 6, 2023

Countdown to the Oscars: Best Animated Short


We’re counting down the days until the Academy Awards! We’ll be here, breaking down each of the 23 categories, talking a bit of history, and trying to figure out who is going to win all those gold statues. So check back throughout the next three weeks for Last Cinema Standing’s Countdown to the Oscars.


Best Animated Short


The nominees are:


The Boy, the Mole, the Fox, and the Horse

The Flying Sailor

Ice Merchants

My Year of Dicks

An Ostrich Told Me the World Is Fake and I Think I Believe It


I have seen every nominee for Animated Short in seven of the past eight years. I only missed 2018 because I was in the process of moving from New York to Los Angeles at the time of the awards, though I did see that year’s eventual winner, Bao, when it played in theaters before The Incredibles 2. Anyway, the point of this is to say that this may be the finest lineup top to bottom that I have seen.


There have been better individual shorts over the years – Don Hertzfeldt’s World of Tomorrow from 2015 is a full-stop masterpiece that comes to mind – but there is often a clunker or two in the group, as well. Not so this year, as every film contains within it something to recommend, from bravura animation to enduring messages about hope and the power of togetherness.


The Boy, the Mole, the Fox, and the Horse – Produced for AppleTV by the likes of JJ Abrams and Woody Harrelson, among others, Charlie Mackesy’s and Matthew Freud’s sweet little film is an adaptation of a bestselling novel with a deceptively simple premise: A boy, lost in the woods, searches for a family. In the process, he meets a Mole (Tom Hollander), a Fox (Idris Elba), and a Horse (Gabriel Byrne), who teach him various lessons about love and forgiveness and finding family where you least expect it.


The hand-drawn animation is truly stunning. In particular, I found myself riveted by the sleek lines on the fox and the effortlessness of his motions. Mackesy’s original novel is a brisk 128 pages, but toward the end of the adaptation, the script starts to feel overstuffed with truisms and homespun affirmations. It all starts to feel a little repetitive, but the film’s heart is in the right place, and it is a big heart indeed.


My Year of Dicks – Frank, funny, and fabulously animated, Sara Gunnarsdóttir’s adaptation of Pamela Ribon’s comic memoir is a gem of a short film and should be seen by adolescents and teens far and wide. The film packs more truth about growing up and dealing with sex into its 24 minutes than any number of TV shows dedicated to the subject ever touch on in their entire runs.


There is humor and humiliation in equal measure as 15-year-old Pam attempts to lose her virginity and chooses wrong guy after wrong guy. The animation matches the emotion on screen beat for beat, flowing freely among a number of stylistic influences. The film has earned numerous accolades from festivals around the country and represents the exact kind of bold, beautifully executed shorts this category is meant to honor.


An Ostrich Told Me the World Is Fake and I Think I Believe It – A fascinating bit of meta commentary on the form of short animation itself, writer-director Lachlan Pendragon’s stop-motion film is insightful, inventive, and flat-out hilarious. It follows an office worker named Neil whose coworkers start disappearing around him. He notices some of his office mates who remain don’t have legs – because if Neil weren’t standing there, they wouldn’t be in the shot. Eventually, he meets the ostrich of the title, and all hell breaks loose.


When Neil breaks into the “real world,” or that of the filmmakers making the very short in which he is starring, it is one of the most ingenious plot developments I have seen in recent years. The whole thing has the energy and wit of Charlie Kaufman’s brilliant Anomalisa but condensed into an 11-minute package. The conclusion is less satisfying than one might have hoped, but the journey there is so stupendous it hardly matters.


Ice Merchants – The first Portuguese animated film to win an award at the Cannes Film Festival, João Gonzalez’s Ice Merchants is a beautiful fable about familial love and environmental stewardship. A father and his young son live on the side of a cliff, where they make ice to sell to the village below. Though obviously dangerous work, they have a routine that makes it feel safe and natural, and most importantly, they have each other. We learn the man’s wife and boy’s mother has died at some point recently and was once an integral part of this ritual.


One day, they awake and there is no ice in their cooler. It is too warm. The cliff above begins to give way as the rest of the ice melts, and the father and son are left stranded beneath an impending avalanche. It is impossible not to see the parallels to the ways real families’ livelihoods are dependent on the natural world and how precariously perched we all are on the brink of ecological disaster. The whole thing concludes on a perfect emotional beat, leaving the audience world weary but hopeful for the future.


The Flying Sailor – Wendy Tilby’s and Amanda Forbis’ The Flying Sailor tells the incredible true story of a sailor who was caught up in the Halifax Explosion of 1917 and thrown through the air nearly 2 kilometers but miraculously survived. In the film, his life flashes before his eyes – and ours – as he soars across the sky, naked as the day he was born. Built on its gorgeous animation, the film is a profound meditation on the fragility and brevity of life.


Tilby and Forbis are the only previous nominees in the category this year. They were previously nominated together in 1999 for their short When the Day Breaks and in 2011 for Wild Life. Tilby also received a solo nomination in 1991 for her film Strings.


The final analysis


For as much time I have spent talking up the quality of all of these films, the victory usually comes down to which movie voters are most aware of, and that usually comes down to which one has the big stars and the big money behind it. This year, that means The Boy, the Mole, the Fox, and the Horse, which has the support of Apple, the big-name producer in Abrams, and the star-studded voice cast. If voters are feeling a little experimental and looking to go outside the box, the likely beneficiary is My Year of Dicks, with a story that is universally relatable and a title that certainly stands out on a ballot.


Will win: The Boy, the Mole, the Fox, and the Horse

Should win: Ice Merchants


Next time: Live Action Short

Saturday, February 18, 2017

Countdown to the Oscars: Best Animated Short

Pixar's Piper is nominated for Best Animated Short.

Welcome to Last Cinema Standing’s Countdown to the Oscars, our daily look at this year’s Academy Awards race. Be sure to check back every day leading up to the ceremony for analysis of each of the Academy’s 24 categories and more.

Best Animated Short


The nominees are:

Blind Vaysha
Borrowed Time
Pear Cider and Cigarettes
Pearl
Piper

Every year, I have to remind myself Pixar has not won this award since 2001. This year represents the company’s ninth nomination since that last victory and 13th overall. It is almost inconceivable it has been 15 years since the greatest modern force in film animation won this award. There is almost certainly no conspiracy here, but it seems an odd coincidence the company has not won the short award since the inception of the Animated Feature category, which it has absolutely dominated.

I am not suggesting other nominees have not been more deserving over the years, but eight straight losses? It strikes me as highly implausible the team producing the best animated features around – hell, some of the best features of any kind, often – is not also doing incomparable work with its short films. So, one must wonder what Pixar has to do to win this award again. This year, I believe Pixar has produced the finest animated short in Piper. I do not believe it will win, but I am at a loss to explain why.

Piper – Writer-director Alan Barillaro’s short played in front of Pixar’s massive smash-hit sequel Finding Dory, so if it has a leg up on the competition anywhere, it is in exposure. Of course, the Pixar shorts have that advantage every year, and it has not produced a victory in quite some time. Barillaro has been with Pixar for nearly 20 years and was a supervising animator on Best Animated Feature winners The Incredibles, Wall-E, and Brave. This is his first film as director, and it is a doozy.

It follows the story of a young sandpiper whose mother tries to teach it to find food on its own. After a traumatic incident involving a rogue wave, the little sandpiper must learn to overcome its fears and join its community on the beach. It is a sweet, simple story, well told and impressively communicated. If that were not enough, it features some of the most photorealistic animation I have ever seen. The water effects in particular are jaw dropping and are alone worthy of honor. It must be seen to be believed.

Pear Cider and Cigarettes – This is the nominee for the adults. You can tell because in theaters, it plays last, after the other nominees and highly commended non-nominees, with a warning to take children out of the theaters. Director Robert Valley uses animation to tell the true story of his relationship with a wild childhood friend, Techno, who is suffering from terminal liver disease and holed up in a military hospital in China.

The film, which runs 35 minutes and is longer than the rest of the nominees combined, is essentially a blow-by-blow account of Techno’s hard-partying lifestyle and later his debilitating illness. It is honest, unsentimental, and unflinching in its account and shot through with a jazzy, neo-noir style that seems a perfect fit for the material. Valley obviously cares deeply for his friend, but the film’s major flaw is that it never gives the audience as much reason to care. The director’s dedication carries the film a long way, but the film ultimately lingers on the surface. As much as it wants us to know Techno, we never get close enough truly to see him.

Pearl – Produced in part by Google, director Patrick Osborne’s touching father-daughter travelogue is the first virtual reality film to be nominated for an Academy Award. It is a laudable achievement and no doubt one of which voters will likely be aware, but I wonder how many will have the opportunity to see it with its full virtual reality setup.

I saw it in a traditional 2D theater environment, and while the story is sweet and relatable, much of the film plays like a glorified, if impressive, music video. This makes sense in a way, since the story concerns a father who gives up his dreams of being a musician to provide a stable life for his daughter only to see her follow his nomadic path out on the road with her band. Osborne won an Oscar in this category two years ago for the visually stunning and emotionally moving Feast. While Pearl does not reach those heights, it is possible voters will be swayed by its technical innovation as much as its story.

Borrowed Time – Spawned from the minds at Pixar but having nothing to do with Pixar, directors Andrew Coats and Lou Hamou-Lhadj spent five years developing this film while working in various capacities on films such as Inside Out, Brave, and Toy Story 3. Their day jobs clearly had a deep influence on the art and style of their side project, but it is unique, both in execution and its decidedly more adult subject matter.

The film depicts an Old West sheriff approaching the scene of a long-ago accident and remembering the feelings of guilt and despair that have brought him back to this place. The animation is lovely, and in particular, the moving clouds in the sky in some of the wide shots are remarkable. The care and effort Coats and Hamou-Lhadj put into the animation is palpable, but the story seems under-baked by just a hair, leaving the audience with more questions than answers. It ultimately feels like a brilliant opening act to a movie I want to see the rest of.

Blind Vaysha – If I explain to you the concept of director Theodore Ushev’s Blind Vaysha, it will sound like a wonderfully intriguing idea. However, you will quickly wonder where this idea goes. Let’s give it a try: Vaysha is born with a condition in which she sees the past through one eye and the future with the other, which means she is perpetually unable to live in the moment. Based on a story by Georgi Gospodinov, Ushev smartly cops to the film’s lack of internal logic and proceeds dream-like through a fable whose moral is stated explicitly to the audience in the final passages.

The Bulgarian filmmaker is a legend in the animation community and rightly so. Blind Vaysha is stunning to look at, replicating a classic wood-cut style with all of the flaws and inconsistencies that make it feel real. The film’s presentation of the dual timelines through which Vaysha sees the world is a feast for the eyes, but with a story that goes nowhere and a simplistic closing scene, Blind Vaysha is probably the least of these nominees and also the least likely to win.

The final analysis


The two most likely winners are Pear Cider and Cigarettes for the scope of its story and its moody presentation and Pearl for its technological breakthrough and heartfelt plotline. I hold out hope Piper can end Pixar’s ridiculous drought in this category, but I won’t count on it. Because I think Academy members will have difficulty identifying the innovation of Pearl without seeing it in its intended virtual reality format, I give the slight edge to Pear Cider and Cigarettes.

Will win: Pear Cider and Cigarettes
Should win: Piper
Should have been here: Inner Workings

Tomorrow: Best Documentary

Monday, February 15, 2016

Countdown to the Oscars: Best Animated Short

Best Animated Short nominee Bear Story tells a moving tale of oppression and loss.

Welcome to Last Cinema Standing’s Countdown to the Oscars, our daily look at this year’s Academy Awards race. Be sure to check back every day this month for analysis of each of the Academy’s 24 categories.

Best Animated Short


The nominees are:

Bear Story
Prologue
Sanjay’s Super Team
We Can’t Live Without Cosmos
World of Tomorrow

I missed the obvious in this category last year, and I will try not to do that again. Last year, I predicted the deeply emotional, beautifully rendered The Dam Keeper to win this category. My reason was that if voters had to see the movies, there is no way they could not vote for it. The rules, however, recently changed, and voters no longer are required to prove they have seen all the shorts to vote on the category. That means the most popular film – or at least, the one most will have seen – is the most likely winner.

That leaves us with two frontrunners this year – a gorgeous little tale of cultural acceptance from the Pixar machine and an epic of futurism and human folly from one of the most inventive and imaginative animators in the business. Any of the other three could win, but Pixar has the name recognition, while Don Hertzfeldt’s short has been on Netflix for months now, making those the two most available nominees. It should not work that way – obviously, it should be about the work, not just who sees the work – but here we are.

Sanjay’s Super Team – Director Sanjay Patel and producer Nicole Paradis Grindle have crafted a gently moving story about a young boy who learns to accept and embrace his culture. The boy, Sanjay, settles in to watch his favorite superhero show, but his father insists he practice their religion first. It is not that Sanjay does not care about Hinduism, but when you are a child, superheroes are a lot more fun. While he is supposed to be in prayerful meditation, Sanjay takes a journey in his mind in which he imagines the Hindu gods as superheroes battling a demon from the darkness.

The animation is beautiful and shifts mediums with ease, portraying the real world in a more classical Pixar style while showing Sanjay’s imagination in a more Saturday morning cartoon style but with the edge and polish of Pixar. Of course, as we said yesterday in discussing Best Original Screenplay, Pixar is a story-first company, and Sanjay’s Super Team builds to an emotionally powerful climax in which both father and son find common cultural ground.

World of Tomorrow – Despite not yet being 40, Hertzfeldt is a legend in the animation world and has created some of the most inventive, influential work of the last 15 years. He is probably most famous for his previous Oscar nominee in this category, Rejected, which was a cult hit before the Internet but blew up in popularity with the advent of YouTube and content-sharing websites. Hertzfeldt has been a cultural force since his early 20s, but he never has lost his independent edge or sardonic view of the world.

World of Tomorrow tells a complex tale of the future, filtered through modern cultural mores and expectations. In the future, there will be cloning and time travel, and people, through their clones, will live for hundreds of years, but the effects will be disastrous, and none of this will hold off the inevitable. A later-generation clone brings her prime, the person from whom she was cloned, forward in time to show her how the world will look and tell her what will be important to her as she grows and experiences more.

It turns into a mediation on humanity and the ways we both waste our time on this planet and find little things to make that time meaningful. The animation, in true Hertzfeldt style, is a shambolic trip through the deteriorating mind of a dying clone. Only Hertzfeldt could create something this funny, this sad, this jarring, and this contemplative and make it both entertaining and thought-provoking.

Bear Story – From Chilean director Gabriel Osorio and producer Pato Escala Pierart, Bear Story is a tragic tale of longing and loss that works on multiple levels as a family drama, political protest, and environmental message. It also features my favorite animation of the bunch, switching styles at its midway point to tell the backstory of its protagonist the way he communicates with the world, through the complex inner workings of a music box.

The story is of an anthropomorphized bear kidnapped from his wife and child and forced to perform in a traveling circus with other kidnapped animals. It is impossible to watch the film and not think of the terrible atrocities committed under the regime of Chilean dictator Augusto Pinochet, and in fact, Osorio’s grandfather was exiled from Chile in the 1970s. If we take it at face value, however, it still communicates an important message about the way we treat the other living beings on our planet – humans included. Finally, it is a simple story of a man (or bear) enduring pain and humiliation but persevering so that he might see his family again someday. Simply, it is wonderful.

We Can’t Live Without Cosmos – Russian writer-director Konstantin Bronzit was previously nominated for his animated short Lavatory Lovestory in 2008. This time, he turns his eye to outer space but keeps his story focused on the simple lives of two people with a dream. We Can’t Live Without Cosmos focuses on two best friends in the Russian cosmonaut program whose only dream their whole lives has been to travel into space. They work hard, have fun, and never lose sight of either their shared dream or their friendship.

When one of them finally is chosen for the mission, everything goes wrong, and the story transitions into one about overcoming depression and finding a way to cope with loss within a dehumanizing system. The animation is simple but effective, and the story incorporates a magical realism that prepares us for the film’s beautiful final passages. There is nothing wrong with We Can’t Live Without Cosmos, but against this field, it feels comparatively lightweight.

Prologue – Director Richard Williams and producer Imogen Sutton’s pencil-drawn Prologue works more like a poem than a traditional story, showing us the violence of men throughout history in the most graphic ways possible. There is nothing wrong with nudity or graphic violence, and in this case, both are natural outgrowths of the story being told, but none of it adds up to much.

The premise seems to be humans – or more specifically, men – have been violent forever, and we should be shocked by that, or it is sad that is the case, or something. For its thematic and storytelling shortcomings, the fluidity and detail of the pencil animation is stunning to behold. A lot of effort ends up onscreen, but that effort means little in the service of something this empty.

Sutton is a first-time nominee, while Williams has been nominated and won twice, once for Best Animated Short in 1972 and once for Best Visual Effects for his animation work on Who Framed Roger Rabbit? He also received a special Academy Award for the animation direction on that film. Williams is a massive talent, but I wish he had applied that talent to a more focused story.

The final analysis


The three best films in this category – Sanjay’s Super Team, World of Tomorrow, and Bear Story – are orders of magnitude better than the other nominees, and if there is any justice, voters will recognize that. Any one of these three would be a deserving, impressive winner. One can never underestimate the Academy’s affinity for hand-drawn, classical animation styles, so Prologue cannot be counted out, but those voters likely will turn to Hertzfeldt. In the end, I think it comes down to Pixar vs. Hertzfeldt, and it just seems more people will have seen the Pixar short.

Will win: Sanjay’s Super Team
Should win: World of Tomorrow
Should have been here: The Short Story of a Fox and a Mouse

Tomorrow: Best Live Action Short

Monday, February 16, 2015

Countdown to the Oscars: Best Animated Short



Best Animated Short nominee The Dam Keeper was directed by Robert Kondo and Daisuke Tsutsumi.

Each day as we make our way to the Academy Awards ceremony Feb. 22, Last Cinema Standing will take an in-depth look at each of the categories, sorting out the highs, the lows, and everything in between. Check back right here for analysis, predictions, and gripes as we inch toward the Dolby Theater and that world-famous red carpet.

Best Animated Short


The nominees are:

The Bigger Picture
The Dam Keeper
Feast
Me and My Moulton
A Single Life

Among the cooler, little-discussed trends in the last decade or so has been the resurgence of the animated short to accompany feature films. Major studios such as Dreamworks and Disney-Pixar have used their celebrated animated films to release equally impressive shorts, while the rise of digital animation has allowed smaller production houses to jump in the game with their own shorts.

John Lasseter, who oversees all of Pixar’s productions won his first Academy Award for Tin Toy, an animated short that was loosely adapted and expanded into Toy Story, which you may recognize as the film that launched the Pixar empire. Walt Disney, who won 22 Oscars, won 12 for Animated Short, including seven consecutive awards from 1934 to 1940.

Walt Disney Studios is in the mix once again this year, as it is almost every year, but a big studio is no guarantee of an Oscar anymore with talent from around the globe producing stunning work in a wide variety of animation styles. The nominees this year come from the U.S., the U.K., Norway, and the Netherlands. They range from just two minutes long to 18, but they all have something vital to say about the world we live in and how our interactions with people can have long-lasting effects.

The Dam Keeper (directed by Robert Kondo and Daisuke Tsutsumi) – I am not certain how anyone could see this film and not name it the best animated short of the year. With no qualifier, this is one of my favorite films of 2014. In just 18 minutes, The Dam Keeper manages to tackle tough subjects such as loneliness, isolation, bullying, the environment, and forgiveness while still telling a touching story about friendship and featuring the most beautiful animation of this group.

In a world populated by anthropomorphic animals, a small pig operates a giant windmill that keeps a poisonous cloud of pollution from overrunning his village. Every morning, he wakes up and gets the windmill spinning to protect the town, then he heads to school, where he is physically and emotionally bullied by his classmates for not being as attractive or smart or popular as they. Despite the abuse from his peers and the indifference of his teachers and other adults, the pig performs his duties to preserve the lives of an ungrateful populace.

It is heady stuff for a cartoon, but it shows just how powerful these shorts can be, stoking feelings of rage, despair, and pain, all for the plight of this little human-like pig. Anyone who has ever been bullied like this knows what it is to feel like nothing you can do will ever make it stop, like the pain will never go away. It is a sad truth that many children live with every day, but most suffer in silence because they are convinced they deserve this, so they walk around invisible to everyone until they truly are gone. The Dam Keeper understands this, and that alone is worth celebrating.

Feast (directed by Patrick Osborne) – As the Walt Disney Studios entry this year, Feast was released to theaters to play before Animated Feature nominee Big Hero 6. It tells the story of one man’s life as seen through the eyes of his faithful, hungry dog. The animation is gorgeous, as one would expect from a Disney production, and the story is straightforward and touching.

Rescued from an alley by the man who becomes his owner, the dog sees the world through the lens of the table scraps and canned food he receives. As the man’s life changes, so does the dog’s food, for better and for worse. What is remarkable about this film is how effortlessly Osborne, working from a story by Nicole Mitchell and Raymond Persi, is able to tell a deeply affecting tale about depression in the background of one adorable dog’s never-ending feast.

A Single Life (directed by Marieke Blaauw, Joris Oprins, and Job Roggeveen) – A brilliant little story that goes by in a flash, I only wish it were longer, but its brevity is the point. A woman receives a mysterious vinyl record. When she plays it, she finds that if she speeds up the record, she can fast forward through her life. If she plays it backward, she goes back in time.

It does not have the fanciest animation of the bunch, but it is clever, entertaining, and surprisingly poignant. In just two minutes of run time, Blaauw, Oprins, and Roggeveen lay out the case for stopping to appreciate the music rather than trying to skip ahead to the good parts because no matter how long it plays, the record will come to an end.

The Bigger Picture (directed by Daisy Jacobs) – Two bickering adult brothers argue over who will care for their dying mother. Though it is clear they were never close, the longer their mother clings to life, the wider the gap between the brothers grows. It is an honest, low-key examination of how strained family relationships can be altered by the death of a loved one, and its story will be familiar to anyone who has experienced a similar situation.

The immediately striking animation is among the most unique and innovative I have seen in recent years, as Jacobs uses six-foot-tall painted characters in life-size sets to tell her story. By filming on live sets, Jacobs imparts a tactile feel to the film that makes the world seem lived in and imperfect, while at the same time giving depth to the frame that is lacking in most non-computer-generated animation. The style is at first startling in its oddness, but ultimately, it is key to creating the reality of the story.

Me and My Moulton (directed by Torill Kove) – Me and My Moulton is about a girl who comes from “the weird family.” You know the one. They don’t dress like everyone else, eat like everyone else, or live like everyone else. For all intents and purposes, they are regular folks. They just seem odd to the outside world, and when you are a child coming of age, there is nothing worse than seeming odd to the outside world. They live above a “normal” family, and all day, the girl wishes her family were more like the downstairs neighbors.

The animation will remind some of children’s cartoons such as those you might find on PBS, and the story of learning to love who you are and where you come from certainly takes its cues from that style of cartoon as well. Kove is the only director in this group who is a previous nominee. She has three nominations in total, and she won this award for her 2006 animated short The Danish Poet, which employed a similar hand-drawn style. The Academy clearly likes her work, but Me and My Moulton is probably at the back of the line this year.

The final analysis


If anything other than The Dam Keeper or Feast wins this award, it will go down as one of the most shocking upsets of the night. The Dam Keeper is the most deserving on both a story and an animation level. Despite wins for big studios in the past, the Academy is rarely swayed by the big names behind a production in this category, usually awarding the best work – a novel concept, I know – but Feast would not be an unworthy winner.

The Bigger Picture won the British Academy of Film and Television award for short animation, but like Boogaloo and Graham in the live action short category, it did not compete there against any of the other Academy Award nominees. The innovation of The Bigger Picture may be enough to sway voters, and the film certainly has an emotional core, but this one probably comes down to the two American films in the lineup, The Dam Keeper and Feast.

Will win: The Dam Keeper
Should win: The Dam Keeper